Cat Sitter: How to Choose the Right One

Picture of Felipe Giaj-Levra
Felipe Giaj-Levra

Reliable Cat Sitting's co-founder and proud owner of 7 cats

Key Takeaways

      • A cat sitter must be responsible, maintaining safety and following specific instructions from pet owners.

      • First aid preparedness is crucial, as emergencies can arise, and the sitter should be trained in basic pet care.

      • Attention to detail is vital, especially regarding routines and habits of each cat to ensure their comfort and well-being.

      • Respect for the owner’s home and the cat’s personal space is essential for a successful cat sitting experience.

      • Ultimately, a true love for animals, particularly felines, is necessary for anyone considering the role of a cat sitter.


    Estimated reading time:
    6 minutes

    Felipe and Simone hold their cat Cindy

    I’ve been cat sitting for a long number of years now. I thought I had seen everything about cats by taking care of my own. But it seems that, with experience, there are many more different animals that I could ever wonder. Each and every one of them with their own behaviour, qualities, quirks and pet peeves. Plus their tutors are obviously different people, with a lot of different expectations for the job. It’s safe to say I’ve also been a substitute pet sitter because of several past issues. For all those reasons, I’ve been reflecting for some time now and I came to the conclusion that I needed to write an article that could help someone to proper vet the person who’s about to take care of their furry loved ones.

    A male cat sitter taking care of a Bengal

    A cat sitter need to be extremely responsible

    Many of the things I’m writing about would seem obvious – and this is an example. I’ve heard many stories of cat sitters that would leave the back door open for a cat to do its business. Or they would just forget to close it. Many people would consider Canada a very safe country (especially London, Ontario), but some cat sitters would forget basic safety measures, such as lock the main doors when leaving, for example.

    The reverse example also happens. I had a client who was adamant that their cat could run free in their backyard while I was sitting him. I thoroughly explained that I could never let his pet roam through the grass alone without some sort of a leash. It was for its own protection. What if the cat got scared with me and decided to run? That’s a definite no-no situation.

    Also: some inexperienced cat sitters would think this is only a light side hustle. I see it differently: we’re dealing with lives here. There’s nothing of more importance than that.

    A Maine Coon cat sits next to a first aid kit

    First aid preparedness is paramount

    I think many people overlook this detail because it’s rare. But it can happen. Imagine the following: a cat is suffering epileptic shock as soon as you begin a sit. Or it’s vomiting too much. What do you do in that situation?

    Because we owned a pet boutique back in the day, we have seen it all. Pets with cardiac problems, diseases, etc. Because of that, my wife Simone and me both have dog and cat first aid courses under our belt. It has served us very well. Simone can even administer medication and apply injections. Plus she is real talented in the art of making a cat ingest a pill. She’s quick and direct… the cat never knew what happened in the first place.

    A girl cat sitter plays with a grey cat

    Attention to details

    Another example of a cat sitter’s responsible attitude is to proper learn the tutor’s instructions. Sometimes, I get 2-3 pages of detailed written tasks. They might seem daunting at first, but I understood that these were vital for the mental well being of someone who is traveling. Sometimes, they are vital to the pet itself. The person is outpouring everything related to an animal’s life. Plus it’s the result of years of living with said animals, so I always take it as very important. I also make sure for the tutor to send me detailed contacts of the cat’s veterinary for any emergency.

    One tutor was specific enough to describe the amount of tea spoons their cat’s food should have and how much water should be heated in the microwave – so then I could mash it and transform it into a pate. Although it seemed over-detailed, I obviously understood why: their cat was 14 years old. The oldies are sometimes more picky when it comes to food. And we need to make sure they are eating properly.

    Another tutor instructed me how to pet their cat correctly. That was fantastic info, because there were tons of no-no petting zones with that cat.

    Overall, I’m glad for the instructions. The more, the merrier.

    A female cat sitter feeds a beige tabby

    You better pay attention to regularity

    Cats love their habits and routines. And as a pet parent, we know a lot about it. But we are human parents as well. As a mom and dad, it can be challenging for us to be extremely punctual in our tasks. That’s why I, as a pet sitter, focus on regularity, not so much punctuality (if the tutor allows). That means I strive to maintain a regular set of intervals between each visit and then try to keep it as best as possible.

    That means if the tutor feels that a drop in every 10-12hours is enough, I’ll make my best to fulfill that gap in time. The cats will notice that regularity and will adapt themselves to it. It’s been working like a charm. Now, if the tutor wants a specific visit time, that can be arranged as well.

    An orange tabby cat rests in a sofa with its eyes closed

    A cat sitter need to be respectful of people’s homes

    In Brazil, we often say ā€œour home is our sanctuaryā€. I take this very much seriously when I’m visiting someone else’s place. Discretion is the word. I don’t snoop around, I don’t touch anything other than the essential nor read anything of theirs. Much less consume or eat anything from their fridge, even if offered. Whenever I start a service as a pet sitter, I locate the kitchen, the litter box, their toys, and, especially, the tutor’s sofa. These are my locations and my tools for the job – and nothing else.

    Simone with a persian cat, doing a cat sitting

    You need to respect the limits of the animal

    I’m very excited when I meet a new cat! I confess. But when I meet and greet, the first thing I’m paying attention to is if the cat is skittish or not. Some cats react to another pet sitter other than their tutor with aggression. In that case, I prefer to leave them alone. Cats like their quietness and their own little sandbox. It’s their comfort zone. As cat sitters, every time we get into people’s homes, we’re kinda dealing with a break in that comfort zone.

    Older cats also need special attention. They usually have pain and cannot be petted in certain areas, much less carried around like babies.

    Felipe sitting his cat Bono at home in London, Ontario

    And, of course – you need to love animals. Especially felines

    It’s also obvious to say this, but… here it goes: if a pet sitter is more of a dogs person, it might not be a good idea for they to be a cat sitter. Cats are wonderful, exquisite animals that are unique in every sense of the word. They have their own moods, atmospheres, behaviours and ways – that might not make too much sense for someone who truly only cares for dogs. Now, if you’re a total animal lover such as we are… then cats are just for you.

    You can find a detailed list of our cat sitting servicesĀ here, complete with job descriptions and everything that we include to make every cat sitting special.

    If everything you read makes sense,Ā let’s talk! So I get to know you and your cat and see if we’re a match.

    Felipe sitting a grey tabby cat